A cover up tattoo in NYC works the same way it works anywhere: by value, not by paint. Dark covers light and never the reverse, which is why a cover up almost always runs larger and darker than the piece underneath. At Lethe Tattoo in the East Village, we read the old ink in person before anything gets drawn.
Most people who book one have been covering the same spot with a sleeve or a watch for years. The question they arrive with is never about style. It is whether the thing can be gotten rid of at all.
Sometimes the answer is no, or not without laser work first, and we would rather tell you that across a table than after a deposit.
What Decides Whether A Tattoo Can Be Covered
Three things, and none of them is how much you hate the old piece. First, how dark it is, since the new design has to sit a full step darker than whatever is underneath. Second, how much room you will give it, because a cover up that stays the same size has nowhere to hide the old lines. Third, where it sits on the body, since a forearm offers less to work with than a shoulder or a thigh. Solid black work and heavy tribal are the hardest, and a faded line tattoo is the easiest thing we see. Most pieces land somewhere between, which is why the answer comes after we look at it rather than before.
Which Designs Actually Bury Old Ink
Not every subject works, and the ones that do have something in common: they carry large areas of solid value and they have a reason to be dark.
Japanese Irezumi tattoo covers well because the background does the job. Clouds, water, and wind bars are already dense by tradition, so they bury lines without looking like they are hiding anything. Dark art and black and grey realism work for the same reason, since shadow is part of the subject rather than a patch laid over it.
Florals cover better than people expect, because petals and leaves give you dozens of small dark edges to place over old linework. Animals with fur or scales do the same.
What rarely works is fine line, lettering, and anything with a lot of open skin in it. There is nowhere for the old tattoo to go.
We will tell you at the consultation if what you want and what your old piece needs are two different things. That conversation is worth having before the drawing starts.
What A Cover Up Tattoo Costs In NYC
A cover up costs more than the same design on clear skin, and it is worth understanding why before you compare quotes.
The drawing takes longer, because it has to be designed around a shape somebody else made. The piece runs larger, since size is what gives the old lines somewhere to disappear. And the saturation takes more passes, because burying ink means building density rather than laying color on once.
Four things move the total. How dark and how large the original is. How much room the new design gets. Whether it is color or black and grey. And whether laser fading comes first, which adds time on the calendar rather than in the chair.
We give you a session estimate at the consultation, once we have seen the old piece in person. A quote given from a phone photo is a guess, and on cover ups guesses run low.
Why Clients Choose Lethe For A Cover Up Tattoo
We Look At The Old Piece Before We Draw
A cover up designed from a photo is a cover up designed blind. Saturation reads differently in person, and so does how the old lines sit against the muscle. Your artist sees it, then draws around what is actually there.
Dark Art And Japanese Are Both In The Room
Cover ups need density, and density is what both of our artists work in. Gusti Negara handles the Japanese composition and background. Philipus Murdijanto has tattooed since 2001 and brings dark art surrealism and black and grey realism. Whichever direction buries your old piece best, it is here.
We Say No When The Answer Is No
Some pieces need laser first. Some need to go bigger than you planned. We would rather lose the booking than hand you a second tattoo you regret.
Long Sittings In A Private Room
Cover ups take more passes than fresh work, which means longer sessions. Our room is on the second floor with no street door and no queue behind you.
When Laser Fading Comes First
Some tattoos need a few laser sessions before a cover up is worth doing. This is not a sales pitch for somebody else's service. It is what happens when the old piece is dark enough that covering it outright would force the new design into solid black.
Two or three laser sessions can lift an old tattoo enough that you get a real design instead of a dark shape. It adds months to the timeline, and most people find that easier to accept than the alternative once they see what full coverage would actually look like.
We will say so at the consultation if that is the honest read. You can come back when the fading is done and we pick up from there.
Tattoo Work From Our East Village NY Studio
Lethe Tattoo
Send Us Your Tattoo Idea
Frequently Asked Questions
Can tattoos be completely covered up?
Most can, but not all of them. What decides it is how dark and how saturated the old piece is, how much room the new design gets, and where it sits on the body. A faded black outline disappears easily. A solid black patch forces the new design into solid black too. We tell you which one you have at the consultation, in person, before you commit to anything.
How much bigger does a cover up have to be?
Plan on noticeably larger. Size is what gives the old lines somewhere to disappear, so a cover up that stays the same size as the original usually fails within a year as the old ink pushes back through. How much larger depends on the old piece. Your artist draws the new design around what is actually there, then shows you the footprint before any needle work starts.
Do I need laser removal before a cover up?
Sometimes, and we will say so plainly if that is the honest read. Two or three laser sessions can lift a dark tattoo enough that you get a real design instead of a dark shape. It adds months to the timeline rather than hours in the chair. Most people accept that once they see what full coverage would actually look like without the fading.
How much should a tattoo cover up cost?
More than the same design on clear skin. The drawing takes longer because it has to work around a shape somebody else made, the piece runs larger, and the saturation needs more passes to bury the old ink. We give you a session estimate at the consultation, once your artist has seen the old tattoo in person. A quote from a phone photo is a guess, and on cover ups guesses run low.
Can you rework a tattoo instead of covering it?
Often yes, and it is the better answer when the old piece has usable line work. A rework keeps what is worth keeping and builds around it, which can mean a smaller piece than a full cover up would need. Dark art and Japanese work are both in the room here, so we can take the design in either direction depending on what the old tattoo gives us.
Do you take clients from Brooklyn, Queens, and New Jersey?
Yes. Most of our large projects come from outside the East Village. Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Astoria, Long Island City, Downtown Brooklyn, and Jersey City are all within about half an hour by train.